The story ends tragically: Luigi attacks Mario but falls into a pit of lava. The game depicts Luigi burning alive while screaming "OH GOD NO," leaving a traumatized Mario weeping on the bridge.

There are two primary ways to experience this story as a playable game: I Hate You: An Unintentionally Scary Mario Creepypasta

Unlike many creepypastas that rely on "haunted" cartridges, "I Hate You" presents itself as a within a standard copy of Super Mario World . The narrator discovers a secret area via a whirlpool on the world map after completing a specific level multiple times. Inside, the atmosphere is nightmarish:

The creepypasta is one of the most famous and unsettling stories in the Nintendo horror subgenre. Originally written as a parody of typical "haunted game" tropes by author Slimebeast in 2012, it unexpectedly gained massive popularity for its dark narrative of brotherly betrayal and has since been adapted into several playable versions. The Story: A Secret Level of Betrayal